Accessibility links

Breaking News

Kremlin Silent About Evidence That Moscow Attack Suspects Were Abused

Updated
(Clockwise from top left) Dalerjon Mirzoev, Faridun Shamsiddin, Muhammadsobir Faizov, and Saidakram Rajabalizoda attend a remand hearing at the Basmanny District Court on March 24.
(Clockwise from top left) Dalerjon Mirzoev, Faridun Shamsiddin, Muhammadsobir Faizov, and Saidakram Rajabalizoda attend a remand hearing at the Basmanny District Court on March 24.

Russian President Vladimir Putin's spokesman refused to answer a question regarding indications that the four suspects in the deadly terrorist attack on a concert hall outside of Moscow may have been abused during and after their detention.

"I am leaving this question without an answer," spokesman Dmitry Peskov said on March 25 after a journalist asked him about the "visible signs of violence" on the suspects when they appeared in court the previous day.

Peskov praised the country's security forces generally, saying they were "working tirelessly and are countering all threats, all challenges facing our country."

He added that Putin would meet with senior officials later on March 25 to discuss the investigation into the March 22 attack, which left 139 people dead and more than 180 injured. Nearly 100 people remain hospitalized.

The Defense Ministry reported on March 25 that the state award called For Courage and the military honor For Military Excellence had been presented by a deputy commander of the Leningrad Military District, Lieutenant General Esedulla Abachev, during a ceremony at the units' base.

Russian officials have said 11 people have been detained in connection with the March 22 attack on the Crocus City Hall concert venue in the Moscow suburb of Krasnogorsk, including four men who are suspected of having carried out the attack.

Moscow's Basmanny district court on March 24 remanded the four men -- Saidakram Rajabalizoda, Dalerjon Mirzoev, Muhammadsobir Faizov, and Faridun Shamsiddin -- into custody for at least two months pending trial on terrorism charges. The court identified the four as Tajik citizens and said they all admitted guilt after being charged.

The court on March 25 remanded three more suspects, including the former owner of the car that the attackers allegedly used to flee. The suspects are Aminjon, Dilovar, and Isroil Islomov. The court did not explain the relationship between the men, but Aminjon and Dilovar have patronymic names indicating they are sons of Isroil.

Dilovar Islomov is believed to be the last owner of the white Renault used by the attackers. The court ordered the Islomovs to remain in pretrial detention until at least May 22.

Evidence continued to emerge that the men may have been tortured during their detention by Russian security forces. All four appeared in court with bruises, bloodstains, and swollen faces.

Before-And-After Images Suggest Severe Abuse Of Moscow Terror Suspects

Dalerjon Mirzoev is seen immediately after his capture in the Bryansk region on March 23. He was captured on suspicion of being one of four Tajik nationals involved in the terrorist attack on a concert hall near Moscow on March 22 that left at least 137 dead and more than 180 injured.
1/8 Dalerjon Mirzoev is seen immediately after his capture in the Bryansk region on March 23. He was captured on suspicion of being one of four Tajik nationals involved in the terrorist attack on a concert hall near Moscow on March 22 that left at least 137 dead and more than 180 injured.
Images taken as four Tajik men suspected of committing the Crocus City Hall shooting near Moscow were apprehended in western Russia on March 23 are starkly different from how the men appeared -- battered and bruised -- in court the following day.
Here is Mirzoev pictured in court in Moscow on March 24 wearing the same long-sleeved T-shirt but sporting signs of being beaten.
2/8 Here is Mirzoev pictured in court in Moscow on March 24 wearing the same long-sleeved T-shirt but sporting signs of being beaten.
Images taken as four Tajik men suspected of committing the Crocus City Hall shooting near Moscow were apprehended in western Russia on March 23 are starkly different from how the men appeared -- battered and bruised -- in court the following day.
Faridun Shamsiddin is shown apparently unscathed immediately after his capture in the Bryansk region on March 23. 
3/8 Faridun Shamsiddin is shown apparently unscathed immediately after his capture in the Bryansk region on March 23. 
Images taken as four Tajik men suspected of committing the Crocus City Hall shooting near Moscow were apprehended in western Russia on March 23 are starkly different from how the men appeared -- battered and bruised -- in court the following day.
Shamsiddin is seen here pictured in court in Moscow on March 24 with a swollen and bruised face. Earlier, the Tajik man was filmed as he was apparently being tortured by security forces with an electrical cable attached to his genitals.<br />
<br />
Aiden Aslin, a British national who was captured by Russia while fighting for Ukraine during the battle of Mariupol, told RFE/RL that he believes the publication of apparent torture of the terror suspects is intended to &quot;set an example.&quot;<br />
<br />
The former Ukrainian marine says such abuse of suspects yet to be found guilty of any crime is at &quot;the same level&quot; as the extrajudicial violence he says he witnessed while in Russian captivity.&nbsp;
4/8 Shamsiddin is seen here pictured in court in Moscow on March 24 with a swollen and bruised face. Earlier, the Tajik man was filmed as he was apparently being tortured by security forces with an electrical cable attached to his genitals.

Aiden Aslin, a British national who was captured by Russia while fighting for Ukraine during the battle of Mariupol, told RFE/RL that he believes the publication of apparent torture of the terror suspects is intended to "set an example."

The former Ukrainian marine says such abuse of suspects yet to be found guilty of any crime is at "the same level" as the extrajudicial violence he says he witnessed while in Russian captivity. 
Images taken as four Tajik men suspected of committing the Crocus City Hall shooting near Moscow were apprehended in western Russia on March 23 are starkly different from how the men appeared -- battered and bruised -- in court the following day.
Saidakram Rajabalizoda is seen as he is led away after reportedly having his ear sliced off by uniformed men who caught him in a forest in Russia&#39;s Bryansk region on March 23.<br />
<br />
The Russian Grey Zone Telegram channel, which is connected to the Wagner group, published a video purportedly showing Rajabalizoda&rsquo;s ear being cut off and security agents trying to force him to eat it. A man in the video yells at the suspect: &ldquo;Chew, bastard! I will cut you open and shove it into your mouth.&rdquo;
5/8 Saidakram Rajabalizoda is seen as he is led away after reportedly having his ear sliced off by uniformed men who caught him in a forest in Russia's Bryansk region on March 23.

The Russian Grey Zone Telegram channel, which is connected to the Wagner group, published a video purportedly showing Rajabalizoda’s ear being cut off and security agents trying to force him to eat it. A man in the video yells at the suspect: “Chew, bastard! I will cut you open and shove it into your mouth.”
Images taken as four Tajik men suspected of committing the Crocus City Hall shooting near Moscow were apprehended in western Russia on March 23 are starkly different from how the men appeared -- battered and bruised -- in court the following day.
Rajabalizoda is seen at his March 24 court appearance with his right ear bandaged and showing evidence of being beaten while in detention.&nbsp;
6/8 Rajabalizoda is seen at his March 24 court appearance with his right ear bandaged and showing evidence of being beaten while in detention. 
Images taken as four Tajik men suspected of committing the Crocus City Hall shooting near Moscow were apprehended in western Russia on March 23 are starkly different from how the men appeared -- battered and bruised -- in court the following day.
Muhammadsobir Faizov is pictured after being apprehended on March 23 with an apparently severe eye injury that has been blurred out by Russian media outlets.
7/8 Muhammadsobir Faizov is pictured after being apprehended on March 23 with an apparently severe eye injury that has been blurred out by Russian media outlets.
Images taken as four Tajik men suspected of committing the Crocus City Hall shooting near Moscow were apprehended in western Russia on March 23 are starkly different from how the men appeared -- battered and bruised -- in court the following day.
Faizov is seen here at a March 24 court hearing. The terror suspect was wheeled into the courtroom and appeared barely responsive during the appearance.&nbsp;
8/8 Faizov is seen here at a March 24 court hearing. The terror suspect was wheeled into the courtroom and appeared barely responsive during the appearance. 
Images taken as four Tajik men suspected of committing the Crocus City Hall shooting near Moscow were apprehended in western Russia on March 23 are starkly different from how the men appeared -- battered and bruised -- in court the following day.
Previous slide
Next slide

Rajabalizoda, whose ear was reportedly cut off during his arrest, had a bandage on the right side of his head. There was no official confirmation that his ear had been severed, and forensic photographs presented in court did not show the injured side of his head.

Earlier, Telegram channels with purported connections to the Russian security agencies published a video purporting to show men cutting off a portion of Rajabalizoda's ear and trying to force him to eat it. The men also threatened to cut off his genitals. According to Russia's Fontanka news agency, the video was first published by Telegram channels connected with the notorious Wagner mercenary group.

Late on March 24, the Grey Zone Telegram channel, which has also been tied to the Wagner group, published a photograph purporting to show men torturing suspect Faridun Shamsiddin. The photograph shows a military radio connected by wire to the suspect's genitals, a well-documented form of torture through electric shock used in the Russian military.

The photograph was accompanied by a mocking text reading: "One of the detained terrorists-migrants from Tajikistan began to lose consciousness from all of the excitement so he was connected to a charger. Despite the fact that he is not a citizen of Russia, the special forces soldiers respected his rights and gave him a telephone to call his lawyer."

In another video, a suspect lying on the ground reads a statement in which he said a cleric had promised him 500,000 rubles ($5,500) to carry out the attack.

State Duma Deputy Aleksandr Khinshtein, who has close ties to the National Guard, wrote on Telegram that some of the suspects were detained near the village of Katsun in the Bryansk region. Security forces allegedly fired at a car carrying the suspects that failed to stop, detaining one on the spot and capturing an unspecified number of others after chasing them in a forest.

Grey Zone published the video purportedly showing the cutting off of Rajabalizoda's ear on March 23, saying the man had been captured in the forest. A man in the video yells at the suspect: "Chew, bastard! I will cut you open and shove it into your mouth." The channel added the comment: "So it will be with all of them."

Moscow Attack Suspects Appear In Court, Amid Signs Of Abuse
please wait

No media source currently available

0:00 0:00:43 0:00

Grey Zone gained prominence in November 2022 when it published a brutal video showing Wagner mercenaries executing a fellow mercenary, convicted murderer Yevgeny Nuzhin, with a sledgehammer.

Russian defense authorities on March 25 said they had presented state and military honors to two units stationed in the western Bryansk region, which borders Ukraine and Belarus, in connection with their purported roles in capturing some of the suspects.

The Defense Ministry reported that the state award called For Courage and the military honor For Military Excellence had been presented by a deputy commander of the Leningrad Military District, Lieutenant General Esedulla Abachev, during a ceremony at the units' base.

The Crocus City Hall attack was the worst terrorist incident in Russian since the 2004 Beslan school siege, in which 333 people, many of them children, were killed. The Islamic State (IS) militant group has claimed responsibility for the attack.

Mourners Pay Tribute To Victims Of Concert Attack In Russia

People comfort each other at the Crocus City Hall concert venue in Krasnogorsk, where a terrorist attack on March 22 claimed the lives of 137 people, including three children, just days after President Vladimir Putin was elected to his fifth term of office.
1/7 People comfort each other at the Crocus City Hall concert venue in Krasnogorsk, where a terrorist attack on March 22 claimed the lives of 137 people, including three children, just days after President Vladimir Putin was elected to his fifth term of office.
People continue to pay their respects at the Crocus City Hall concert hall in Krasnogorsk, outside Moscow, where a terrorist attack on March 22 claimed the lives of more than 130 people, including three children.
Russian officials have said 11 people have been detained in connection with the March 22 attack on the concert venue in the Moscow suburb of Krasnogorsk, including <a href="https://www.rferl.org/a/russia-crocus-suspects-torture-abuse-state-honors/32876123.html" target="_blank">four Tajik nationals</a>&nbsp;who are suspected of having carried out the attack.
2/7 Russian officials have said 11 people have been detained in connection with the March 22 attack on the concert venue in the Moscow suburb of Krasnogorsk, including four Tajik nationals who are suspected of having carried out the attack.
People continue to pay their respects at the Crocus City Hall concert hall in Krasnogorsk, outside Moscow, where a terrorist attack on March 22 claimed the lives of more than 130 people, including three children.
A toy teddy bear and a drawing are seen at the impromptu memorial.
3/7 A toy teddy bear and a drawing are seen at the impromptu memorial.
People continue to pay their respects at the Crocus City Hall concert hall in Krasnogorsk, outside Moscow, where a terrorist attack on March 22 claimed the lives of more than 130 people, including three children.
In a brief statement on March 22, the Islamic State (IS) extremist group said it was behind the attack. The following day, it released a photograph of what it said were the four attackers, all masked.
4/7 In a brief statement on March 22, the Islamic State (IS) extremist group said it was behind the attack. The following day, it released a photograph of what it said were the four attackers, all masked.
People continue to pay their respects at the Crocus City Hall concert hall in Krasnogorsk, outside Moscow, where a terrorist attack on March 22 claimed the lives of more than 130 people, including three children.
In addition to the scores killed, more than 180 people were injured in the attack.
5/7 In addition to the scores killed, more than 180 people were injured in the attack.
People continue to pay their respects at the Crocus City Hall concert hall in Krasnogorsk, outside Moscow, where a terrorist attack on March 22 claimed the lives of more than 130 people, including three children.
The Crocus City Hall attack was the worst terrorist incident in Russia since the 2004 Beslan school siege, in which 333 people, the majority of them children, were killed.
6/7 The Crocus City Hall attack was the worst terrorist incident in Russia since the 2004 Beslan school siege, in which 333 people, the majority of them children, were killed.
People continue to pay their respects at the Crocus City Hall concert hall in Krasnogorsk, outside Moscow, where a terrorist attack on March 22 claimed the lives of more than 130 people, including three children.
Lit candles forming the words &quot;We Mourn 22.03.2024&quot; are placed outside the Crocus City Hall concert venue on a national day of mourning on March 24.
7/7 Lit candles forming the words "We Mourn 22.03.2024" are placed outside the Crocus City Hall concert venue on a national day of mourning on March 24.
People continue to pay their respects at the Crocus City Hall concert hall in Krasnogorsk, outside Moscow, where a terrorist attack on March 22 claimed the lives of more than 130 people, including three children.
Previous slide
Next slide

In his comments on March 25, Kremlin spokesman Peskov declined to comment on U.S. assertions it had warned Moscow in advance of a possible terrorist attack in the capital. He also said Moscow has had "no contacts" with the West since the attack.

He added that he was "not authorized" to comment on the IS claim of responsibility. Putin, in a televised address on March 23, also failed to mention the IS statement and hinted, without providing evidence, of a possible Ukrainian connection to the attack.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy and other officials have vigorously denied the allegations.

Peskov also said the Kremlin was not involved in calls by parliamentarians and other top officials and pro-Kremlin media personalities to restore the death penalty following the Crocus City Hall attack.

"We are not taking part in the discussion at the moment," Peskov said.

  • 16x9 Image

    RFE/RL's Russian Service

    RFE/RL's Russian Service is a multi-platform alternative to Russian state-controlled media, providing audiences in the Russian Federation with informed and accurate news, analysis, and opinion.

  • 16x9 Image

    Current Time

    Current Time is the Russian-language TV and digital network run by RFE/RL.

This item is part of
XS
SM
MD
LG