Accessibility links

Breaking News

Watchdog

An Orthodox nun holds an icon during a protest against the international LGBT event EuroPride in Belgrade on August 28.
An Orthodox nun holds an icon during a protest against the international LGBT event EuroPride in Belgrade on August 28.

Opposition parties and global rights groups on August 28 blasted the Serbian government’s decision to cancel an international LGBTQ EuroPride event scheduled for next month.

Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic on August 27 acknowledged that the rights of sexual minorities are threatened in Serbia but said the government had come under intense pressure from right-wing groups and representatives of the Serbian Orthodox Church to cancel the event.

“It is not a question of whether [those pressures] are stronger,” Vucic said. “It’s just that at some point you can’t achieve everything, and that’s it.”

Vucic allowed for the possibility that the event could be held at a later date.

EuroPride promotes lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and intersex pride at the pan-European level and is hosted by a different European city each year. The event includes a Pride Parade.

The UN’s Belgrade office said it was concerned about the cancellation, saying it would jeopardize “the right to freedom of assembly as guaranteed by the Serbian Constitution.”

“The EuroPride is also an opportunity to celebrate the foundations of a strong and progressive society based on social equity, equality of all rights, solidarity, friendship, and love,” UN Resident Coordinator in Serbia Francoise Jacob said.

The Civic Democratic Forum opposition party accused Vucic of “playing dictator” and modeling himself after Russian President Vladimir Putin.

Forum leader Zoran Vuletic said Vucic “cannot cancel an event that he did not schedule and he cannot, according to the constitution, prohibit the gathering of people.”

Kristine Garina, president of the European Pride Organizers Association which licenses EuroPride, issued a statement saying the event would not be canceled despite Vucic’s remarks.

“The right to hold Pride has been ruled by the European Court of Human Rights to be a fundamental human right,” Garina said.

European Pride Organizers Association three years ago chose Belgrade to host the annual event, hoping it would represent a major breakthrough for a Slavic country that is traditionally conservative and under strong influence from the Orthodox Church.

Also on August 28, right-wing groups and political parties, church representatives, and others gathered in Belgrade in support of the cancellation of the EuroPride parade.

Many carried crosses, icons, and church symbols, with some displaying banners supporting Putin and the Russian invasion of Ukraine.

On the same day that Vucic announced the cancellation of the parade, he also proposed extending the term of Serbia’s prime minister, Ana Brnabic, who is a lesbian but who has been accused by Serbia’s gay rights groups of not doing enough to help their status in the country. She joined Vucic in supporting the canceling of the EuroPride event.

“No matter how you turn it, from any angle you look at it, the first inviolable thing is to ensure peace and stability in the country,” Brnabic said.

Serbia held its first gay-pride parade in 2001 and the event was met by violence and angry counterprotests by far-right and nationalist groups. At the next Belgrade pride parade, in 2010, more than 100 people were injured.

However, a third gay-pride parade was organized in 2014 and the event passed without serious incident. Since then, annual pride parades have been held peacefully in Belgrade each year, except for 2020 when the event was canceled due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

With reporting by RFE/RL's Balkan Service and AP
Khursheda Kholmurodova (left) was 25 and a student at a medical college when she took her own life by drinking a fatal dose of vinegar. The parents of Manora Abdufattoh, 25, believe their daughter was either killed or driven to suicide by her in-laws.
Khursheda Kholmurodova (left) was 25 and a student at a medical college when she took her own life by drinking a fatal dose of vinegar. The parents of Manora Abdufattoh, 25, believe their daughter was either killed or driven to suicide by her in-laws.

KHATLON REGION, Tajikistan -- Sanat Ghafforova jumped into the Sirdaryo River near her home in northern Tajikistan along with her two young children after allegedly enduring abuse by her in-laws for five years.

The bodies of the 27-year-old mother and her children were found the next day, on June 30.

Prosecutors in the Sughd region have since charged Ghafforova's mother-in-law, Mahbuba Saidolimova, with driving her to suicide, a crime punishable by up to eight years in prison.

“From the beginning of her marriage [in 2017], Ghafforova faced mistreatment by her mother-in-law and other members of her husband’s family who often verbally abused and insulted her,” prosecutor Furqat Khojazoda told reporters. “They also beat her occasionally.”

A joint study in 2016...concluded that 97 percent of men and 72 percent of women in Tajikistan believed a woman must tolerate domestic violence in order to keep her family together.

The in-laws deny the accusations.

Tajik courts have recently sentenced several in-laws -- both men and women -- for impelling their daughters-in-law to commit suicide by subjecting them to emotional and physical abuse, insults, and stirring conflict between husbands and wives.

Activists and the State Committee for Women and Family Affairs have long raised alarms about the negative roles some in-laws have played in marital crises or even the collapse of their sons’ marriages.

Women’s Center Gulrukhsor, which provides counselling, legal advice, and temporary shelter for victims of domestic violence, says about half of the women who seek help from the group blame their in-laws for most of their marital issues.

Dozens of young women in Tajikistan have taken their own lives over marital problems in recent years. Some of them, like Ghafforova, tragically ended their children’s lives, too.

In the past, law enforcement agencies often found husbands responsible for domestic violence and driving their spouses to suicide. But in recent years Tajik prosecutors have turned their attention to the roles some in-laws play in bringing deadly ends to their sons’ marriages.

In Tajikistan, where families often live in multigenerational houses, some parents get involved excessively in their sons’ marriages. Tajik tradition dictates that sons take their parents’ side in any conflict, as siding with a wife is seen as weakness.

Some of the problems in such households have been linked to financial issues. With miserable pensions and a lack of other social-welfare provisions, many elderly parents depend almost entirely on their children’s support.

It’s also not uncommon for many families to treat their daughters-in-law as unpaid maids responsible for doing household chores and taking care of their husbands and his parents.

'For Others To Take Notice'

In the first-known criminal case targeting in-laws, the district court in Sangvor -- one of the most conservative parts of the country -- sentenced Zuhro Jurabekova, 63, to 5 1/2 years in prison for impelling her daughter-in-law to suicide.

Fariza Khujanazar
Fariza Khujanazar

The woman pleaded partially guilty in the death of 21-year-old Fariza Khujanazar, who took her own life after just two years of marriage.

Khujanazar, who had a 1-year-old son, reportedly said she could no longer cope with the insults, criticism, and humiliation she suffered at the hands of her mother-in-law.

In a rare move, the judge ordered the trial to be held in an open space with locals in attendance to “send a powerful message” to other abusive families.

That case came after the women’s committee and its regional departments reported a significant rise in the number of complaints filed by women alleging harsh treatment by their in-laws.

In the southern region of Khatlon alone, authorities said at the time that they were dealing with more than 300 such complaints.

The sentencing in Sangvor was followed by several other similar court cases, as the number has increased noticeably in the past year.

While many cases involved mothers-in-law, Emom Zabirov, a 64-year-old resident of the southern village of Zarnisor, became the first man in Tajikistan to be jailed for driving a daughter-in-law to suicide.

Gulbahor Faromarzova
Gulbahor Faromarzova

Gulbahor Faromarzova, 18, hanged herself after enduring “relentless criticism, nagging, and verbal abuse” from Zabirov, according to the prosecution.

Zabirov, who plead not guilty, was sentenced to five years and two months in prison.

A man in the Dusti district of Khatlon Province was imprisoned along with his son for the “cruel” treatment of his daughter-in-law, “mentally abusing her,” and “forcing her to work at a farm without a day off” in the summer heat, media reported. The woman hanged herself.

In the town of Tursunzoda, Zarkhol Mustonova was handed a five-year sentence for the emotional abuse of her daughter-in-law, Khursheda Kholmurodova, a student at a medical college. Kholmurodova, 25, took her own life by drinking a fatal dose of vinegar last year.

In the eastern district of Faizobod, the parents of Manora Abdufattoh, 25, are seeking justice for their daughter, who they believe was either killed or driven to suicide by her in-laws. Her body was found with knife wounds to her stomach and neck. Prosecutors said on July 2 that initial probes showed that she had taken her own life, but investigations continue.

Training Classes For In-Laws

According to Tajik activists, many cases of domestic abuse go unreported because women fear the stigma attached to getting a divorce.

A joint study in 2016 by the women’s committee, a local research organization, and the British group Oxfam concluded that 97 percent of men and 72 percent of women in Tajikistan believed a woman must tolerate domestic violence in order to keep her family together.

Authorities say they are working with neighborhood committees and religious figures to tackle this tragic social problem.

Women’s Center Gulrukhsor has conducted more than 70 training sessions this year involving some 700 mothers-in-laws and fathers-in-law in an effort to reduce domestic violence. The group has also trained 350 neighborhood committee members and 70 police officers who deal with domestic violence issues.

RFE/RL’s Tajik Service contributed to this report.

Load more

About This Blog

"Watchdog" is a blog with a singular mission -- to monitor the latest developments concerning human rights, civil society, and press freedom. We'll pay particular attention to reports concerning countries in RFE/RL's broadcast region.

Subscribe

Journalists In Trouble

RFE/RL journalists take risks, face threats, and make sacrifices every day in an effort to gather the news. Our "Journalists In Trouble" page recognizes their courage and conviction, and documents the high price that many have paid simply for doing their jobs. More

XS
SM
MD
LG