Accessibility links

Breaking News

Watchdog

Mohammad Hosseini was hanged in an Iranian prison on January 7.
Mohammad Hosseini was hanged in an Iranian prison on January 7.

While Mohammad Hosseini's execution was intended as a message from Tehran that involvement in ongoing antiestablishment protests will not be tolerated, his memory lives on as a victim of state repression.

The 39-year-old poultry worker and community-minded coach had no support from those closest to him as he faced charges of killing a member of Iran's paramilitary forces as mourners demonstrated in a city outside the Iranian capital in November.

After being found guilty of "corruption on Earth" in a rushed trial, Hosseini received no visits from friends and relatives as he sat on death row. Nobody, not even his three siblings, pleaded publicly for his life to be spared before he was hanged in early January, and reports suggest that no one immediately claimed his body.

His brother, with whom Hosseini did not have a close relationship, was given his body only after he promised "not to speak to anyone and bury him in silence" sources told RFE/RL's Radio Farda.

But in the weeks following his death, Hosseini has been increasingly embraced by supporters who see themselves as "mothers," "brothers," and "sisters" of a victim of state repression who lived a simple life, dealt with medical conditions, and gave to the community by training impoverished children in the martial arts.

Hosseini was hanged on January 7 along with 22-year-old Mohammad Mehdi Karimi. The two were convicted for the November 3 killing of Basij militia member Ruhollah Ajamian in Karaj, a city just west of Tehran.

Authorities said Ajamian died from multiple blows from "knives and other hard objects, including stones" allegedly delivered by a group of mourners marking 40 days since the death of a demonstrator. The slain protester is just one of more than 500 victims of Iran's violent crackdown on the mass demonstrations that broke out in over 100 cities across the country following the death in police custody of Mahsa Amini in September. The 22-year-old woman had been detained for allegedly not wearing her hijab, or head scarf, properly.

According to the Iranian authorities, Ajamian was unarmed when he was attacked while attempting to open a road closed by the mourners.

Hosseini and Karimi, who were sentenced to death following a fast-tracked trial in which they were not given access to legal representation of their choice, each denied the allegations against them.

Their trial lasted less than a week and relied on confessions the men gave under torture, according to Amnesty International, which noted that state media aired potentially damning video testimony even before their case got to court.

Hosseini, who reportedly dealt with bipolar disorder, was shown saying that he was on his way to the cemetery in Karaj to visit his parents' graves when he saw "a young man who had fallen to the ground."

"Because I have mental issues, I ran away," he said in the video, which also included images of martial arts weapons taken from Hosseini's home as evidence.

"These are for sports, dear," Hosseini said when asked about the weapons.

Allegations Of Torture

In another video also published by state media, he said he spent "less than 10 seconds" at the scene of Ajamian's killing, and suggested that the Basij member was already dead.

Lawyer Mohammad Sharifzadeh Ardakani, who was initially barred from representing Hosseini, said on December 18 that he managed to meet him in prison, where the accused tearfully said he had been tied up, kicked in the head, and shocked with electricity to make him confess to his alleged crimes.

"A person's confession under torture has no legal merit," Ardakani said on Twitter. He was subsequently charged over his comments and released on bail.

Ardakani later said that after Hosseini was convicted he filed for a retrial, but had not managed to convince the court to halt the death sentence. He said he found out about his client's execution as he headed to discuss the case with the authorities.

Details about Hosseini's luckless life led to an outpouring of grief and sadness. A photo taken during his trial where he was seen holding his face in an apparent state of shock and disbelief went viral.

"I think about your loneliness, the mother you didn't have to cry for you, the father who wasn't there to shout your name," journalist Sadaf Fatemi wrote on Twitter.

Gohar Eshghi, the mother of blogger Sattar Beheshti killed in 2001 in the custody of Iran's cyberpolice, called on authorities to hand Hosseini's body over to her. Camelia Sajadian, whose son Hassan Torkman was reportedly killed in Iran's ongoing crackdown on antiestablishment protests, announced that she had arranged for a headstone for Hosseini, referring to him as her "dear son."

Others have visited Hosseini's grave and showered it with flowers, distributed food to the poor in his memory, or offered their condolences with comments on his Instagram page, which quickly gained over 60,000 followers.

"I didn't know you until three weeks ago, I hadn't heard your name and I had no idea who you were. But now I visit your page and cry for you like a sister who has lost a brother," one woman commented under a photo in which Hosseini was shown practicing martial arts.

Mohammad Hosseini was a champion in several martial arts, including kung fu.
Mohammad Hosseini was a champion in several martial arts, including kung fu.

Hosseini's workplace, by contrast, did not allow any kind of memorial for him, one of his colleagues to Radio Farda, while other sources said he was never informed that his execution was imminent.

"Usually prisoners [on death row] are taken to solitary confinement the night before their hanging, but Hosseini was not taken to a solitary cell," one source told Radio Farda on condition of anonymity. "[The authorities] did not want anyone to find out that he was about to be executed."

Hosseini is one of four people who have been hanged in Iran in connection with the nationwide protests that began in September.

The executions have been condemned inside and outside the country, with UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Turk saying that they amount to "state sanctioned killing."

Rights groups have warned that about two dozen more who have been sentenced to death or await trial are at risk of being executed.

Financier and activist Bill Browder (file photo)
Financier and activist Bill Browder (file photo)

TBILISI -- U.S.-born financier and political activist Bill Browder has accused doctors involved in treating imprisoned former Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili of being "probably involved" in malpractice and taking orders from government officials.

Known for his lobbying for the Magnitsky Act, a sanctions list targeting Russian officials responsible for the death of Russian tax lawyer Sergei Magnitsky in 2009 in a Moscow prison, Browder has now vowed to create a similar list of those involved in keeping Saakashvili in prison.

In a tweet, Browder promised Saakashvili that he will "do whatever I can to bring this to the attention of Western governments for Magnitsky sanctions."

Following his arrest in October 2021 after illegally crossing into Georgia, Saakashvili, who was president from 2004 to 2013, has staged repeated hunger strikes in protest against his imprisonment. His health appears to have deteriorated significantly while incarcerated. He is currently serving a six-year prison sentence on charges of abuse of power, which his supporters claim are politically motivated.

International support for the 55-year-old former president has grown over the last few weeks in tandem with the visible decline of Saakashvili's condition in the military hospital facility where he is now receiving treatment.

At a court hearing on January 17, British orthopedic traumatologist James Cobb, who is working as part of an international team to examine Saakashvili, noted that the patient's neck "was stiff, he felt severe pain, and he could not bend his head to the left. There was also severe pain in the left shoulder area [and] he could not move his left arm. His left shoulder and left wrist area were very weak."

He added that Saakashvili should undergo surgery on his neck, left shoulder joint, and left hip joint. "If these operations are not carried out, it will be difficult for him to move every day, and it will become even more difficult, and he will not be able to walk and move," he added.

In an interview with RFE/RL's Georgian Service, Browder said, "If Saakashvili dies in prison, the consequences will be disastrous for those responsible."

A screengrab from a video released by Georgia's penitentiary service, showing Mikheil Saakashvili at a medical clinic in December.
A screengrab from a video released by Georgia's penitentiary service, showing Mikheil Saakashvili at a medical clinic in December.

"Two weeks ago, photos of what [Saakashvili] looks like after being arrested and tortured were released. These were the most disturbing, horrifying photos I have seen since Sergei Magnitsky was killed by slow torture," Browder said in the interview.

"I made it very clear publicly how shocked I was, as were many other people. I tweeted this message, and then I got a response from Mr. Saakashvili, obviously through a member of his team. He was basically asking me for help, begging me for help. I felt immense sympathy for him. I don't want anything worse than what has already happened. I think he should be let out of jail," Browder said.

'This Is An Emergency'

According to Browder, he is currently waiting for evidence supplied by Saakashvili's lawyers, which would confirm the violations of Saakashvili's rights as well as naming those who have abused them.

Once the evidence has been collected, Browder says he plans to present it to governments, engaging with politicians and political bodies who have shown sympathy towards the imprisoned former president and have voiced alarm at his mistreatment.

"It's very simple," Browder says. "Documentary or other evidence proving that he was tortured, ill-treated, or treated negligently. It could be that the judge ignored his request that he needed medical attention, that the prosecutors imposed certain prison conditions on him, or the evidence could be the actions of the police officers who were somehow involved in his case.... It could also be about those who stand above all these people, to government officials if there is evidence that it was a political order. I don't want to prejudge the evidence because I haven't received it yet. What I can assess are the photos of Mikheil Saakashvili, which clearly show that he was treated badly. There are no more questions about it."

Public international alarm has quickly grown in recent weeks, with heads of state and diplomats, including Moldovan President Maia Sandu, EU Ambassador to Georgia Pawel Herczynski, and U.S. Ambassador to Georgia Kelly Degnan, expressing concern over Saakashvili's health and urging the Georgian government to ensure the protection of his rights.

After the incumbent Georgian Dream government recently publicized edited footage of the former president in his hospital room, it then accused Saakashvili of exaggerating his illness.

On December 1, 2022, Saakashvili asked the court to release him from prison or postpone his sentence due to the need for treatment abroad.

Mikheil Saakashvili was president of Georgia from 2008 to 2013. (file photo)
Mikheil Saakashvili was president of Georgia from 2008 to 2013. (file photo)

"The more the process drags on, the more problems it will bring to the Georgian government," says Browder. "They shouldn't be torturing a former president in a politically motivated situation. He definitely has signs of torture, signs of deteriorating health. This is the shame of Georgia, the shame of the Georgian government, and the shame of the Georgian justice system."

"This is an emergency. His condition is rapidly deteriorating," Browder adds. "It's like a person on the verge of death, so it's not something that can be put off. It should be done very quickly. I think the other cases related to his mistreatment should have been completed at the same time. This [making the list] is just one tool in the fight to save his life.

Written by Nadia Beard in Tbilisi based on reporting by RFE/RL's Georgian Service.

Load more

About This Blog

"Watchdog" is a blog with a singular mission -- to monitor the latest developments concerning human rights, civil society, and press freedom. We'll pay particular attention to reports concerning countries in RFE/RL's broadcast region.

Subscribe

Latest Posts

Journalists In Trouble

RFE/RL journalists take risks, face threats, and make sacrifices every day in an effort to gather the news. Our "Journalists In Trouble" page recognizes their courage and conviction, and documents the high price that many have paid simply for doing their jobs. More

XS
SM
MD
LG